Monday, January 26, 2009

Wholegrain Banana Bread, the Good Kind

Here's the thing all the bran & germ hippies need to know: that bitter, gritty flavor of wholegrain bread, that flavor you pretend to relish? There's a reason you don't actually like it, deep in the crystalline magnetic reaches of your rainbow souls. It's not that you're an accountant in disguise. It's that underfermented wholegrain breads are, in fact, bitter and gritty and pretty much taste like yeast excrement.

Well, I guess that leaves us with... sourdough. All well and good, the sourdough. Such long, slow fermentations, so much intensity, texture, character, whatnot. Marvelous stuff.

But what about that banana bread? It only gets a little baking powder rise in the oven -- no fermentation there, to break down the bitter grit and make us a nice sweet strong loaf. And yet, we want some.

Oh look, here comes the dairymaid to the rescue. You can ferment quick breads (banana bread, cornbread, muffins) with yogurt to get a silky rich tender nubbly bread, with all the germ and bran melted into a creamy batter. My recipe is adapted from Sally Fallon's Nourishing Traditions.

I make this stuff in batches when I have bunches of overripe bananas from Bi-Rite, and then freeze loaves of it to surprise W. Crawford in later, poorer days. Speaking of whom, note the funny little grin at the top of this picture. I was so engrossed in my banana bread photo shoot that I didn't notice my visitor for another two pictures. I hope you're similarly oblivious to the street-grime on my window.

Banana Bread

24 hours before baking, stir together in a large bowl:
6 cups whole grain kamut flour, wheat flour, or spelt flour
4 cups acidic liquid, being: yogurt, kefir, or water + a splash of raw vinegar
Cover with a plate and let sit till tomorrow.

The next day, butter 3 large loaf pans, preheat the oven to 350 degrees, and mash:
6 large overripe bananas

Whisk in:
6 eggs
1 T. vanilla extract
2 tsp. salt
1 T. baking soda
3/4 cup honey or maple syrup or other sugar
1/2 c. butter, melted (and browned slightly, if you like)
1 cup chopped walnuts or pecans or dark chocolate chips (optional)

When well combined, add to the soaked flour mixture and stir until thoroughly mixed. I use my hands. Pour into the buttered pans and bake until well browned and a knife comes out clean, somewhat more than an hour. Let cool for a bit in the pans, then run a knife around the edges and ease the loaves out.

Wrapped in plastic when cool, this bread keeps well for days at room temperature. Or wrap tightly and freeze.

13 comments:

Marjorie Nafziger said...

Yesterday I just did similarly to the Italian Bread recipe in Simply in Season - by soaking the flour in yogurt most of the day(my improv) before proceeding with the rest...parmesan/onion/garlic in this is good, but I think adding herbs would make it even better.

dressedinburgundy said...

Love the title of this post!! Haha. And the rest of it, I'll be sure to try when I get some bananas...

Laura said...

I have an excessive amount of dark rye flour (say, twenty pounds or so) and i would LOVE to find ways to use it up. Would this recipe work with rye flour?

Rosanna said...

I'm sure rye would work -- the bread may not be quite so fluffy, but no doubt it will be delicious!

Laryssa @ Heaven In The Home said...

Thank you! I have been looking for a soaked banana bread recipe for a while. This was wonderful! I made muffins and loaves...both turned out well.
I used honey for the sweetener and the muffins were just right, not overly sweet. Thanks so much! I'll send others here to see your recipe and share the goodness!

Kendra said...

Help! I just can't seem to get this to turn out right and I want to so bad. It is always way too brown on the outside and gooey on the inside. The first time it was down right sour. So the second time I added more sucanat and less acid, more water. This time it is sweet enough, but still gooey. I guess i need to turn the oven temp down, but I am afraid to try it again.

rjmorb5 said...

Kendra- Same here. I used 1/2 cup maple syrup and 1/4 cup honey and my bread is super dark, yet not done inside. I am using glass pans and so I know you should go down 25 degrees on the temp which I did not do. I will try 1 more time lowering temp and see how it goes. For now I have 4 loaves of gooey bread...what can I do with that?! :) Thanks

dwebster said...

I have been known to fill muffin cups half full with not-quite-done bread (as well as old, stale bread, and just leftover perfect bread-- all soaked, of course!) and pour over it beaten eggs (our own happy, free-range of course!) to fill the cup. Add whatever you like to enhance flavor-- if it is plainer than banana bread, adding spices or cheese or bacon (grass-fed, homegrown of course!)is nice. I bake these in stoneware at 400 until golden and puffy after soaking them overnight. (I am not good in the mornings and like to prep my meals the night before.) Packed with goodness and protein they make a good start to the day- and a good snack later on.

Rosanna said...

Hmm. I'm perplexed that this isn't working for some of you! One thing to check is the acidity of the liquid you're using--if it's not acidic enough, it won't react with the baking soda to leaven the loaf. A loaf that doesn't rise properly will be too dense to bake through.

Lightening up on the bananas a bit may help. They certainly contribute a good deal of moisture, particularly if they're on the ultra-ripe end of the spectrum.

And a lower oven temperature does help even out the dark crust / gooey inside problem. This recipe does make a moister, tangier loaf than the standard fluffy-cakey banana bread, but by no means should it be gooey!

Well, it sounds like it's time for me to make some more banana bread and see if I can't come up with some more potential solutions.

meg said...

I found you and this great recipe on my google hunt for soaked quick breads. I put my flour to soak yesterday and whipped up the remainder this afternoon adding crispy pecans and chopped organic milk chocolate. I used 4 loaf pans and baked in a convection oven at 350 for one hour. The loaves end up being rather squat but the taste and texture are absolute perfection - thank you! My husband and kids inhaled a half loaf at tea time. Yum!

Andrea said...

I tried a similar recipe and also had trouble with the inside being undercooked. I soaked in yogurt, but would buttermilk have been better? Would that make a difference? If anyone has any other tips, please help us!!

JennyCash said...

hi, i know this post is dated, but i tried this recipe this morning, soaking my whole wheat flour in a mixture of buttermilk and goats milk kefir overnight (15+ hours). the loaves baked through, but collapsed a little on themselves, which wasn't a big deal. the issue was the texture - it was very, very dense and spongy, not bread-like at all. i assumed it would be a little different than traditional bread but not that much. i wouldn't even bother to ask except it looks so far from your picture that i am wondering what could have gone wrong. any ideas?

The Rozell Family said...

I made this today and halved the recipe. I used 2 cups freshly ground whole wheat and 1 cup of rye flour. I used 2 1/2 cups coconut milk and 1/2 cup sourdough starter for the liquid. I also used sucanat instead of the honey/syrup and the recipe turned out great. I soaked the grains and liquid overnight.